vitamins
10 seasons
Players & Lineups
Record book · Lineup Decisions

Costliest Start/Sit Call

Biggest gap between a starter and an eligible benched player who outscored him.

Record holder
−44.3
dylan
Started Brian Robinson Jr. (7.0) over De'Von Achane (51.3) · 2023 W3
See the matchup
  1. 1
    D
    dylan
    Started Brian Robinson Jr. (7.0) over De'Von Achane (51.3) · 2023 W3
    −44.3
  2. 2
    E
    evan
    Started Devonta Freeman (5.1) over Sammy Watkins (46.8) · 2019 W1
    −41.7
  3. 3
    E
    evan
    Started David Johnson (0.2) over Chase Edmonds (35.0) · 2019 W7
    −34.8
  4. 4
    J
    joshua
    Started Jonathan Williams (3.5) over James White (37.7) · 2019 W13
    −34.2
  5. 5
    T
    Tyler
    Started Travis Kelce (5.7) over George Kittle (39.6) · 2021 W13
    −33.9
  6. 6
    J
    jonah
    Started Jeremiyah Love (2.3) over Tyler Allgeier (36.1) · 2026 W8
    −33.8
  7. 7
    C
    Coby
    Started Kirk Cousins (10.1) over Daniel Jones (43.8) · 2019 W16
    −33.7
  8. 8
    A
    Aidan
    Started Aaron Jones Sr. (3.6) over Tony Pollard (36.5) · 2026 W7
    −32.9
  9. 9
    S
    Spencer
    Started Allen Robinson (8.0) over Calvin Ridley (40.5) · 2018 W3
    −32.5
  10. 10
    C
    Coby
    Started Michael Crabtree (1.7) over Larry Fitzgerald (33.9) · 2017 W3
    −32.2
  11. 11
    E
    evan
    Started Brandin Cooks (0.0) over Michael Thomas (31.8) · 2016 W12
    −31.8
  12. 12
    Z
    Zach
    Started Darrell Henderson Jr. (8.8) over James Conner (40.3) · 2021 W9
    −31.5
  13. 13
    S
    Spencer
    Started Patrick Taylor Jr. (2.7) over Zack Moss (33.5) · 2023 W5
    −30.8
  14. 14
    C
    Coby
    Started Kadarius Toney (0.0) over Joshua Palmer (30.6) · 2022 W11
    −30.6
  15. 15
    E
    Ethan
    Started Benny Snell Jr. (3.1) over A.J. Brown (33.6) · 2019 W14
    −30.5
  16. 16
    M
    Max
    Started David Montgomery (1.2) over Kenny Gainwell (31.4) · 2025 W4
    −30.2
  17. 17
    A
    Aidan
    Started Amari Cooper (3.7) over Robert Woods (33.7) · 2018 W3
    −30.0
  18. 18
    T
    Tyler
    Started Greg Dortch (1.7) over Darnell Mooney (31.5) · 2024 W5
    −29.8
  19. 19
    M
    Max
    Started Julio Jones (2.6) over Terrelle Pryor Sr. (32.3) · 2016 W3
    −29.7
  20. 20
    E
    evan
    Started Michael Gallup (0.0) over Tyler Boyd (29.5) · 2022 W7
    −29.5
  21. 21
    E
    evan
    Started Marshawn Lynch (3.6) over Jordan Howard (32.6) · 2017 W3
    −29.0
  22. 22
    C
    Coby
    Started Michael Crabtree (0.0) over Marvin Jones Jr. (28.9) · 2017 W12
    −28.9
  23. 23
    D
    dylan
    Started Jameson Williams (0.6) over Rachaad White (29.1) · 2024 W7
    −28.5
  24. 24
    S
    Spencer
    Started Davante Adams (8.2) over Tyreek Hill (36.5) · 2017 W13
    −28.3
  25. 25
    E
    evan
    Started Calvin Ridley (4.0) over Brandin Cooks (32.3) · 2023 W10
    −28.3
  26. 26
    M
    Max
    Started Josh Allen (25.3) over Aaron Rodgers (53.1) · 2019 W7
    −27.7
  27. 27
    S
    Spencer
    Started Mike Gillislee (3.1) over Chris Thompson (30.8) · 2017 W3
    −27.7
  28. 28
    J
    jonah
    Started Jordan Addison (0.0) over Cole Kmet (27.6) · 2023 W4
    −27.6
  29. 29
    E
    evan
    Started Golden Tate (4.1) over Rob Kelley (31.7) · 2016 W11
    −27.6
  30. 30
    M
    Max
    Started Darnell Mooney (0.0) over Zay Jones (27.5) · 2022 W12
    −27.5
  31. 31
    E
    Ethan
    Started DJ Moore (0.3) over Mike Evans (27.7) · 2018 W1
    −27.4
  32. 32
    C
    Coby
    Started Tyler Lockett (1.9) over Ladd McConkey (29.1) · 2024 W8
    −27.2
  33. 33
    E
    evan
    Started Colin Kaepernick (2.2) over Matthew Stafford (29.3) · 2016 W13
    −27.1
  34. 34
    Z
    Zach
    Started Falcons (3.0) over Vikings (30.0) · 2025 W3
    −27.0
  35. 35
    L
    Lewis
    Started Joe Burrow (7.0) over Jared Goff (34.0) · 2025 W2
    −26.9
  36. 36
    C
    Coby
    Started Latavius Murray (5.0) over Myles Gaskin (31.9) · 2021 W5
    −26.9
  37. 37
    C
    Coby
    Started Larry Fitzgerald (5.1) over Michael Crabtree (32.0) · 2017 W2
    −26.9
  38. 38
    E
    evan
    Started Ben Roethlisberger (14.7) over Deshaun Watson (41.6) · 2017 W4
    −26.8
  39. 39
    C
    Coby
    Started James Robinson (2.9) over Miles Sanders (29.6) · 2022 W4
    −26.7
  40. 40
    S
    Spencer
    Started Will Fuller V (6.1) over Emmanuel Sanders (32.7) · 2016 W3
    −26.6
  41. 41
    E
    evan
    Started Jordan Howard (2.2) over Jay Ajayi (28.6) · 2016 W7
    −26.4
  42. 42
    L
    Lewis
    Started Jamaal Charles (0.0) over LeGarrette Blount (26.4) · 2016 W7
    −26.4
  43. 43
    M
    Max
    Started Ty Montgomery II (2.8) over Lamar Miller (29.1) · 2017 W4
    −26.3
  44. 44
    A
    Aidan
    Started Lamar Jackson (4.7) over Matthew Stafford (30.9) · 2025 W16
    −26.1
  45. 45
    J
    jonah
    Started Parker Washington (2.0) over Tyquan Thornton (28.1) · 2026 W4
    −26.1
  46. 46
    M
    Max
    Started Thomas Rawls (3.8) over Mark Ingram II (29.7) · 2016 W12
    −25.9
  47. 47
    C
    Coby
    Started Ben Roethlisberger (19.6) over Andrew Luck (45.3) · 2018 W4
    −25.7
  48. 48
    Z
    Zach
    Started Sony Michel (7.9) over James Conner (33.5) · 2021 W14
    −25.6
  49. 49
    M
    Max
    Started Parker Washington (4.0) over Kenny Gainwell (29.5) · 2025 W11
    −25.5
  50. 50
    M
    Max
    Started Jonathan Mingo (3.7) over Jakobi Meyers (29.1) · 2023 W1
    −25.4
  51. 51
    O
    oren
    Started Sammy Watkins (3.7) over Marquise Goodwin (29.1) · 2018 W6
    −25.4
  52. 52
    O
    oren
    Started Adrian Peterson (0.0) over Rex Burkhead (25.3) · 2017 W13
    −25.3
  53. 53
    O
    oren
    Started Danny Woodhead (4.1) over Travis Benjamin (29.4) · 2016 W2
    −25.3
  54. 54
    Z
    Zach
    Started Geronimo Allison (2.4) over Adrian Peterson (27.6) · 2018 W8
    −25.2
  55. 55
    S
    Spencer
    Started Devin Funchess (6.2) over Allen Robinson (31.3) · 2018 W10
    −25.1
  56. 56
    C
    Coby
    Started Alvin Kamara (5.7) over Jamaal Williams (30.8) · 2017 W14
    −25.1
  57. 57
    D
    dylan
    Started Joshua Kelley (3.9) over Brian Robinson Jr. (28.9) · 2023 W2
    −25.0
  58. 58
    M
    Max
    Started Christine Michael (6.1) over Mark Ingram II (31.1) · 2016 W9
    −25.0
  59. 59
    E
    Ethan
    Started Calvin Ridley (5.0) over Romeo Doubs (29.8) · 2025 W4
    −24.8
  60. 60
    A
    Aidan
    Started Cam Newton (12.6) over Derek Carr (37.4) · 2017 W7
    −24.8
  61. 61
    T
    Tyler
    Started Ronald Jones (0.4) over Jamaal Williams (25.0) · 2021 W1
    −24.6
  62. 62
    O
    oren
    Started Michael Crabtree (6.1) over Sammy Watkins (30.7) · 2018 W8
    −24.6
  63. 63
    A
    Aidan
    Started Josh Downs (5.7) over Jordan Addison (30.2) · 2024 W12
    −24.5
  64. 64
    Z
    Zach
    Started Josh Jacobs (7.4) over D'Onta Foreman (31.8) · 2022 W8
    −24.4
  65. 65
    J
    jonah
    Started Willie Snead IV (0.0) over Charles Sims (24.4) · 2016 W3
    −24.4
  66. 66
    M
    Max
    Started Justin Fields (4.0) over Jaxson Dart (28.4) · 2025 W7
    −24.4
  67. 67
    AJ
    A.J.
    Started Sammy Watkins (0.0) over Michael Gallup (24.3) · 2019 W5
    −24.3
  68. 68
    E
    evan
    Started Sterling Shepard (6.5) over Golden Tate (30.8) · 2016 W6
    −24.3
  69. 69
    S
    Spencer
    Started Cam Akers (5.3) over D'Andre Swift (29.5) · 2024 W4
    −24.2
  70. 70
    Z
    Zach
    Started Amari Cooper (2.9) over Anthony Miller (26.8) · 2019 W15
    −23.9
  71. 71
    S
    Spencer
    Started Amari Cooper (1.8) over Davante Adams (25.6) · 2017 W5
    −23.8
  72. 72
    C
    Coby
    Started Alex Smith (12.3) over Blake Bortles (36.1) · 2016 W8
    −23.8
  73. 73
    O
    oren
    Started Ben Roethlisberger (10.4) over Kirk Cousins (34.2) · 2016 W11
    −23.8
  74. 74
    S
    Spencer
    Started Jeff Wilson Jr. (11.0) over Cam Akers (34.7) · 2022 W16
    −23.7
  75. 75
    S
    Spencer
    Started Corey Coleman (1.9) over Chris Thompson (25.6) · 2017 W2
    −23.7
  76. 76
    L
    Lewis
    Started Quentin Johnston (0.0) over Keenan Allen (23.6) · 2024 W12
    −23.6
  77. 77
    O
    oren
    Started Lamar Jackson (24.0) over Russell Wilson (47.4) · 2019 W3
    −23.5
  78. 78
    J
    jonah
    Started Brock Purdy (16.2) over Drake Maye (39.5) · 2026 W5
    −23.3
  79. 79
    L
    Lewis
    Started A.J. Brown (6.9) over Puka Nacua (30.1) · 2023 W2
    −23.2
  80. 80
    E
    evan
    Started Alexander Mattison (4.9) over Kyren Williams (28.0) · 2023 W2
    −23.1
  81. 81
    E
    evan
    Started DJ Moore (-0.1) over Tre Tucker (22.9) · 2026 W2
    −23.0
  82. 82
    J
    joshua
    Started Jalen Richard (3.6) over Kenyan Drake (26.6) · 2018 W12
    −23.0
  83. 83
    E
    Ethan
    Started Vikings (3.0) over Broncos (26.0) · 2016 W8
    −23.0
  84. 84
    J
    jonah
    Started Keke Coutee (0.0) over Miles Sanders (22.8) · 2019 W8
    −22.8
  85. 85
    C
    Coby
    Started Julio Jones (4.4) over Nelson Agholor (27.1) · 2017 W13
    −22.7
  86. 86
    C
    Coby
    Started Christian Kirk (2.8) over Corey Davis (25.5) · 2018 W10
    −22.7
  87. 87
    C
    Coby
    Started Michael Crabtree (7.0) over Marvin Jones Jr. (29.7) · 2017 W9
    −22.7
  88. 88
    A
    Aidan
    Started Dante Pettis (1.7) over Jamison Crowder (24.3) · 2019 W1
    −22.6
  89. 89
    Z
    Zach
    Started Russell Wilson (10.7) over Tom Brady (33.2) · 2018 W14
    −22.5
  90. 90
    S
    Spencer
    Started Rhamondre Stevenson (4.6) over Mark Andrews (27.1) · 2025 W3
    −22.5
  91. 91
    Z
    Zach
    Started Noah Fant (3.5) over Dalton Schultz (26.0) · 2021 W3
    −22.5
  92. 92
    D
    dylan
    Started Allen Robinson (7.2) over Kadarius Toney (29.6) · 2021 W5
    −22.4
  93. 93
    A
    Aidan
    Started Phillip Dorsett II (3.2) over Coby Fleener (25.6) · 2016 W6
    −22.4
  94. 94
    S
    Spencer
    Started Robert Woods (5.6) over Mecole Hardman Jr. (28.0) · 2022 W7
    −22.4
  95. 95
    M
    Max
    Started Mark Ingram II (3.0) over James Robinson (25.4) · 2021 W3
    −22.4
  96. 96
    J
    joshua
    Started Marqise Lee (0.0) over Marquise Goodwin (22.4) · 2017 W15
    −22.4
  97. 97
    M
    Max
    Started Kirk Cousins (23.2) over Matt Ryan (45.6) · 2016 W4
    −22.4
  98. 98
    J
    jonah
    Started Carson Wentz (22.3) over Russell Wilson (44.6) · 2017 W8
    −22.4
  99. 99
    O
    oren
    Started Carson Wentz (5.4) over Philip Rivers (27.7) · 2018 W11
    −22.3
  100. 100
    E
    Ethan
    Started Michael Pittman Jr. (3.5) over Brian Robinson Jr. (25.7) · 2026 W4
    −22.2
100 of 1424 entries

Only games that mattered count: regular-season games and playoff games while a team was still alive in the winners bracket. Consolation games, third-place games and weeks after elimination are left out of every record.